Screenless wearables - less screen time?


Recently, I received a beautiful Swiss watch as a birthday gift. But this meant I had to take off my Apple Watch, which I'd been wearing for more than six years already. So I took my Apple Watch off, put it in a drawer… and never put it back on.

After a couple of days I realized I never wanted to check my rings, or take a look at my sleep score. I never missed the fact that my wrist vibrates every time I receive a message or a call. Having to react to every notification actually made me anxious, because urgent messages from my boss and a video with a cute cat from my friend vibrated in the exact same way.

I also learned that my iPhone can track my steps. And that my new Maurice Lacroix looks so much cooler.

The only thing I miss from any smartwatch is a wake-up alarm that gently taps my wrist. There was a period in my life when I worked night shifts and slept in chunks during the day. Back then I took sleep tracking rather seriously and had specific sleep goals, which required me to sleep 2-3 times a day to hit them. A smart wake-up alarm was part of what I'd call sleep hygiene or sleep politeness: when you and your family keep different schedules, you don't want a loud alarm meant for someone else's 3 a.m. shift to wake up the whole house. That's what got me looking into simpler, screenless wearables.

Now the market offers two types of screenless wearables: bands like Whoop, and smart rings like Oura or Ultrahuman. Both track similar things - sleep, recovery, activity - but they sit on your body differently. A ring disappears on your finger; a band is closer to a watch I've just swapped the screen out of. I started with the ring.

At first, I really liked the idea of a smart ring. Smart rings like Oura or Ultrahuman can monitor sleep, activity, cycle metrics, body temperature, and more. You're supposed to just live your life and wear a rather small ring as often as possible. Lack of screen is supposed to be less distracting, right?

Image not found or invalid format

Most rings can also auto-detect activities, whether it's housework, a walk, or some serious sport. The data they collect is presented nice and neat in an app on your phone. But if the ring itself has no screen, you end up spending more time on your phone checking what happened during the day. How did I sleep? How many calories did I burn? What's my readiness score?

Whoop launched around the same time as Oura, and somehow became a flex for people who made working out their entire personality. Every gym bro compares their recovery. Some got so obsessed with these metrics that they ended up trusting Whoop more than themselves or their own bodies.


Image not found or invalid format

And then came AI.

In 2023, Whoop introduced Whoop Coach, a feature built on OpenAI's GPT-4 that turns your own data into a conversation.

Instead of reading a dashboard, you ask it plain questions: why your recovery dropped, whether you should train today. And it answers using thousands of your own biometric data points, fine-tuned on Whoop's performance research.

A year later, Oura followed with Oura Advisor.

"Advisor is your in-app health and wellbeing assistant," says Johanna Still, UX Writing Manager and Head of Insights at Oura. "It helps make sense of your data — whether it's your sleep, activity, or recovery trends — by providing context and insights that go beyond the numbers."

By 2026, Google went all in: it rebranded Fitbit into Google Health and launched the Fitbit Air, a $99 screenless tracker paired with a Gemini-powered coach that folds your sleep, activity, and nutrition data into an ongoing conversation about your health, sold, naturally, as a $9.99-a-month subscription.

Which says something on its own. We've built devices that generate more personal data than most of us know what to do with, and the fix isn't fewer metrics, it's another layer of AI hired to interpret them for us. What was supposed to make health simpler just added a new thing to depend on.

And here come some serious privacy concerns. Health, sleep, cycle, and for some devices GPS data are about as sensitive as personal data gets. Yet most of us have no real sense of where it goes once it leaves the app. We accept the terms of service without reading them, we don't check whether a company publishes a transparency report, and "infrequent government requests" is a phrase most people scroll past without asking what it actually means in practice. Oura has confirmed it does receive occasional requests from governments to hand over user data, though it doesn't share numbers on how many, or how it responds to them. The company was also at the center of a separate backlash after a press release for a new manufacturing facility mentioned Palantir's FedStart platform, used to secure a Department of Defense-only version of the ring for military personnel. Oura says regular customer data stays fully separate and isn't accessible to the Pentagon or Palantir; not everyone found that reassuring.

There's also a more personal version of this fear. I live in Russia, and Sber, which is one of the country's largest state-owned banks, makes its own smart ring. On paper, it's not that different from an Oura: same sensors, same promises about sleep and recovery. But it would never occur to me to actually buy one and wear it. Trusting Oura or Whoop with my data already requires some leap of faith. Trusting a device made by a company that answers, one way or another, to the same government that could someday ask for that data is a different kind of trust I'm not willing to give. I'd rather hand my body's data to a foreign company I'll never meet than to one sitting a phone call away from people who could actually use it against me.

So, back to my own experiment. I recently went to the gym without any wearable tracker - just me, my headphones, and a dumb watch. I worked out, and afterward I just went and ran errands. No cheap dopamine hit from a calorie count. Just feeling tired. I don't even really enjoy sport, I do it to break up a pretty sedentary life, nothing more. I used to think tracking it with the Apple Watch would gamify the process, or at least make it less boring. It didn't. The best part of my workout is still the moment it's over and I get to go home. Turns out a beautiful chart of how I performed never changed that.

This essay wasn't meant to be an anti-wearable statement. I love tech, and I'm genuinely curious about what's coming next. But the line between real benefit and tracking for tracking's sake is one I'm still trying to find.

Never miss a post

Get new writing sent to your inbox.

Subscribe